Question of depth perception in lithophanes

Gallery for images of work cut using PhotoVCarve
Post Reply
Stickman
Vectric Craftsman
Posts: 225
Joined: Fri May 22, 2009 5:20 pm
Model of CNC Machine: Legacy Arty 58
Location: El Sobrante, California

Question of depth perception in lithophanes

Post by Stickman »

Sorry if I'm clogging up the forum, but I'm working hard to dial in my parameters on lithophanes. At least I'm giving lots of folks something to look at. :wink:

This beach scene (a photo for an old girlfriend's Maui vacation) didn't come out nearly as well as I'd expected, mainly because the difference in depth of the carving throws off perspective, at least IMO. The contrast, especially the face, looks odd at too many angles. I actually prefer the shallow results I previously got in .125 acrylic! What's interesting is that this is the first piece I've done where the photographic image of the work looks better than the carving itself.

This was done in 1/4" corian, cut to .21" in a single pass with a 30° bit. For the first time I deleted the rapid clearance gap using notepad, after first changing the last Z-clearance to .1" so it wouldn't be deleted on the search/delete. Total time to cut 4"x3.75" was just over 3 hours. Estimated time was 1hr 17min. This is still in line with the roughly 240% over estimate I was getting before, so I don't know how much effect eliminating the clearance gave gave me.

There's a bit of graininess because the original photo was too small, so I had to enlarge it (I used Kneson Imagener, made specifically for enlargements, which generally gives a better result than algorithms in other programs). I'm wondering if I'd get enough contrast if I used VCarve Pro to cut out a pocket and then do the carving with less depth.

At first I thought the bit I used (photo #2) might have affected quality. While both bits in the photo are 30°, the one on the right is very fine, as the tip of the shaft is cut in half, while the left bit, which I used for the first time, is square cut. (I chose the new bit because the tip of the other broke when my Z-axis didn't stop on command going down. The difference isn't visible, but it isn't as insanely sharp as before.) However, when I compared the bit profile to the cutting depth, there doesn't seem to be any significant difference.
Attachments
Tiny sailboats on horizon don't really show up (one on either side of her).  Those dark dashes from her left cheek across her right eyebrow are just weird!
Tiny sailboats on horizon don't really show up (one on either side of her). Those dark dashes from her left cheek across her right eyebrow are just weird!
Square cut 30° bit on left, half-profile cut on right.
Square cut 30° bit on left, half-profile cut on right.

calgrdnr
Vectric Wizard
Posts: 970
Joined: Tue Mar 20, 2007 6:29 am
Model of CNC Machine: ShopBot prt with 4g upgrade
Location: Visalia, Ca

Re: Question of depth perception in lithophanes

Post by calgrdnr »

Clean the litho with a fine stainless steel ( NOT brass ) tooth brush like brush, and liquid dish soap .
it will clean up the Klingons and look Much better then the picture posted .... IMHO Kent


please repost after you clean it :)

calgrdnr
Vectric Wizard
Posts: 970
Joined: Tue Mar 20, 2007 6:29 am
Model of CNC Machine: ShopBot prt with 4g upgrade
Location: Visalia, Ca

Re: Question of depth perception in lithophanes

Post by calgrdnr »

difference isn't visible, but it isn't as insanely sharp as before
If itis just the tip les then .03 you are ok at least all mine have turned out fine

Stickman
Vectric Craftsman
Posts: 225
Joined: Fri May 22, 2009 5:20 pm
Model of CNC Machine: Legacy Arty 58
Location: El Sobrante, California

Re: Question of depth perception in lithophanes

Post by Stickman »

I'm not throwing way the tip-less bit; it's still about as sharp as the 4-sided one. Considering these cost me about a buck apiece on ebay, though, I'm not too worried. It's the $28+ bits I hate breaking!

Off to work; no steel brush here now, but I'll see what I can do to clean this up first chance I get. The depth of cut/contrast on the cheekbone still throws me off though ....

Greolt
Vectric Wizard
Posts: 999
Joined: Fri Sep 21, 2007 1:44 pm
Model of CNC Machine: UCCNC Router, Plasma, Laser
Location: Australia 3781

Re: Question of depth perception in lithophanes

Post by Greolt »

Stickman wrote: The depth of cut/contrast on the cheekbone still throws me off though ....
I use vee bits to cut lithophanes all the time but there is one disadvantage. It is not possible to machine a vertical wall.

At best the wall will have a slope equal to half the bit's included angle.

For most photos this is no problem, but sometimes it will show up on a hard light/dark transition. Will give a halo sort of appearance.

I sometimes have this problem around the eyes. Transition from white of the eye to the iris/pupil. Can make for weird looking eyes. :)

Of course this will be less pronounced with a 30 degree cutter than a 60 degree.

Greg

Stickman
Vectric Craftsman
Posts: 225
Joined: Fri May 22, 2009 5:20 pm
Model of CNC Machine: Legacy Arty 58
Location: El Sobrante, California

Re: Question of depth perception in lithophanes

Post by Stickman »

Hmm, so has anyone tried a 20° v-bit? Probably a bit extreme, and would take that much longer ....

Greolt
Vectric Wizard
Posts: 999
Joined: Fri Sep 21, 2007 1:44 pm
Model of CNC Machine: UCCNC Router, Plasma, Laser
Location: Australia 3781

Re: Question of depth perception in lithophanes

Post by Greolt »

I guess the ideal would be very small ballnose.

I don't have any. :)

As I say though, for most pictures a vee bit works perfectly.

They are also fairly robust. I never do a roughing pass on a lithophane.

Greg

Post Reply